Cadillac ATS

The Cadillac ATS, once hailed as a contender in the compact luxury sedan segment, has struggled to maintain its reputation due to various issues. Common complaints include subpar interior quality, lackluster performance compared to rivals, and reliability concerns. While it offers engaging handling and a range of engine options, the ATS falls short in terms of overall refinement and long-term ownership satisfaction.

Lincoln MKZ

The Lincoln MKZ, positioned as an entry-level luxury sedan, disappoints with its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. Despite attempts to revitalize the brand with modern styling cues and a comfortable ride, the MKZ fails to stand out in a competitive market dominated by more compelling offerings from rival automakers.

Jaguar XE

The Jaguar XE, marketed as a sporty alternative in the compact luxury sedan segment, has been plagued by reliability issues and lackluster performance compared to its German competitors. While it boasts attractive styling and agile handling, the XE falls short in terms of interior quality, technology features, and overall driving refinement, making it one of the least desirable options in its class.

Volvo S60

The Volvo S60, known for its emphasis on safety and Scandinavian design, struggles to compete with rivals due to its uninspiring performance, lackluster interior materials, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a comfortable ride and a range of advanced safety features, the S60 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and value for money, making it a less appealing choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Audi A3

The Audi A3, positioned as the entry point into the Audi lineup, fails to impress with its cramped rear seats, lackluster performance, and dated interior design. Despite offering a range of engine options and available all-wheel drive, the A3 lacks the refinement and driving dynamics expected from a luxury compact sedan, making it one of the least desirable choices in its segment.

Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class

The Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class, marketed as a more affordable entry into the luxury brand, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and subpar ride quality. While it boasts stylish exterior design and a range of available features, the CLA-Class falls short in terms of overall refinement and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it one of the worst choices in the luxury compact sedan segment.

BMW 2 Series

The BMW 2 Series, positioned as a sporty and agile option in the luxury compact car segment, fails to live up to its reputation due to various issues. Common complaints include cramped rear seats, lackluster interior materials, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers potent engine options and engaging handling, the 2 Series falls short in terms of overall refinement and value for money compared to its rivals.

Lexus IS

The Lexus IS, known for its reliability and strong resale value, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and limited technology features. Despite offering a smooth ride and a range of available options, the IS falls short in terms of driving dynamics and overall refinement, making it a less compelling choice in the luxury compact sedan segment.

Infiniti Q50

The Infiniti Q50, marketed as a sporty and luxurious option in the midsize sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of engine options and available all-wheel drive, the Q50 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and value for money compared to its competitors, making it one of the least desirable choices in its class.

Acura ILX

The Acura ILX, positioned as an entry-level luxury sedan, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and outdated technology features. Despite attempts to inject some sportiness into the model, the ILX falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it one of the least compelling options in the luxury compact sedan segment.

Alfa Romeo Giulia

The Alfa Romeo Giulia, hailed for its stylish design and engaging driving dynamics, suffers from reliability issues, lackluster interior quality, and limited practicality. While it offers potent engine options and agile handling, the Giulia falls short in terms of overall refinement and long-term reliability, making it a risky choice for buyers seeking a dependable luxury sedan experience.

Genesis G70

The Genesis G70, positioned as a strong contender in the luxury sport sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped rear seats, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and a comfortable ride, the G70 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least desirable options in its class.

Buick Verano

The Buick Verano, marketed as a premium compact sedan, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and limited technology features. Despite offering a smooth ride and a quiet cabin, the Verano falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less appealing choice for buyers seeking a luxury sedan experience.

Cadillac CT4

The Cadillac CT4, positioned as a sporty and agile option in the luxury compact sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the CT4 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least compelling choices in its class.

Lincoln Continental

The Lincoln Continental, known for its luxurious amenities and spacious interior, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, dated design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a smooth ride and a range of available features, the Continental falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less desirable choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Jaguar XF

The Jaguar XF, marketed as a stylish and refined option in the midsize luxury sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped rear seats, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available engines and a comfortable ride, the XF falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least desirable options in its class.

Volvo S90

The Volvo S90, known for its emphasis on safety and Scandinavian design, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced safety technology, the S90 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less appealing choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Audi A4

The Audi A4, known for its luxurious amenities and refined interior, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped rear seats, and limited practicality. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the A4 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it one of the least compelling choices in the luxury compact sedan segment.

Mercedes-Benz C-Class

The Mercedes-Benz C-Class, hailed for its luxurious amenities and elegant design, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the C-Class falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less desirable choice for luxury sedan buyers.

BMW 3 Series

The BMW 3 Series, known for its sporty driving dynamics and upscale interior, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped rear seats, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available engines and advanced technology, the 3 Series falls short in terms of overall driving excitement and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less compelling choice in the luxury compact sedan segment.

Lexus ES

The Lexus ES, positioned as a comfortable and luxurious option in the midsize sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a smooth ride and a range of available features, the ES falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less desirable choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Infiniti Q70

The Infiniti Q70, marketed as a spacious and luxurious option in the midsize sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped rear seats, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the Q70 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least compelling choices in its class.

Acura RLX

The Acura RLX, known for its spacious interior and comfortable ride, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced safety technology, the RLX falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less appealing choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Alfa Romeo Stelvio

Image Credit: MercurySable99/WikiCommons.

The Alfa Romeo Stelvio, marketed as a sporty and luxurious option in the compact luxury SUV segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers engaging handling and stylish exterior design, the Stelvio falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it one of the least desirable choices in its class.

Genesis G80

The Genesis G80, known for its spacious interior and extensive list of standard features, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a smooth ride and a range of available options, the G80 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less compelling choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Buick LaCrosse

The Buick LaCrosse, positioned as a comfortable and spacious option in the full-size sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a smooth ride and a range of available features, the LaCrosse falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less desirable choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Cadillac CT5

The Cadillac CT5, marketed as a sporty and luxurious option in the midsize sedan segment, disappoints with its lackluster performance, cramped interior, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the CT5 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least compelling choices in its class.

Lincoln MKZ

The Lincoln MKZ, known for its comfortable ride and spacious interior, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and advanced technology, the MKZ falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less appealing choice for luxury sedan buyers.

Jaguar XJ

The Jaguar XJ, positioned as a flagship luxury sedan, disappoints with its lackluster performance, dated interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a range of available features and a comfortable ride, the XJ falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and interior refinement, making it one of the least desirable options in its class.

Volvo S80

The Volvo S80, known for its emphasis on safety and comfort, struggles to compete with rivals due to its lackluster performance, uninspired interior design, and below-average reliability ratings. While it offers a smooth ride and a range of available features, the S80 falls short in terms of overall driving dynamics and long-term ownership satisfaction, making it a less compelling choice for luxury sedan buyers.