For this article, we purchased a collection of winter wool and synthetic socks. We then wore them as evenly as possible over a four-year period. During that time, we exposed our socks to the harsh winters of Maine and just about every activity you can imagine in New England and Colorado. We even tracked our indoor usage to determine which socks handled the wear and tear of extreme indoor loafing. Along the way, we’ve developed some strong opinions about which of these brands offers the toughest socks. In some cases, our findings fit well with other research we’ve done focused on the warmest wool socks that are best for the most extreme weather conditions.

Tough Socks for Extreme Activities & Professions

Although we tried to narrow our review down to socks that function well across all activities, we felt it would be helpful to organize our recommendations across different activities and professions listed below. For each category and profession, we’d like to think we found the toughest sock in the world.

General outdoor activity (best all-around)
Military personnel and firefighters
Hunting & fishing
Extreme laziness around the house (without slippers)
Hiking and backpacking
Skiing & snowboarding
Bicycling

Our Toughest Sock Picks

As you’ll see below, we had to come up with our own rating system to help evaluate the most durable socks. Based on our observations of our tested socks over the last 4-5 years, we landed on the following criteria to determine which socks have the most value: overall durability, hole resistance, warmth, thread wear, color over time, price (value) and warranty.

Among these criteria, we felt that it was most important to find a sock that has a lifetime warranty and that is as durable, comfortable, hole proof as possible. Thankfully, we found socks that score high on all of our criteria based on our four-year testing period. If you look closely at some of our photos for this article, you’ll also see that various brands didn’t hold up well after a year or two. We’d like to think that means that we’ve essentially found socks that last forever. To help lengthen the life of your socks so they are as indestructible and puncture proof as possible–since nothing lasts forever (sorry)–we’ve also included some helpful information at the end of this post about sock materials, which socks match with various types of activities and how to wash and care for your socks to prolong their life. Next, let’s talk about how we grouped our toughest socks in terms of different extreme weather activities and even professions.

1. Best Overall Toughest Sock

If you’re wondering what the best overall toughest sock is in the world, look no farther: it’s the Darn Tough Hiker Boot Full Cushion sock. Don’t let the reference to “hiker” concern you. This is the sock we use year round for just about any activity where a tough, hole-resistant, well-insulated sock is needed. And “yes,” this is a great summer sock as well when hiking or pursuing your outdoor passion since Merino wool breathes exceptionally well. With the heel cushion, these socks also seem to last forever–even for extreme indoor lazy wear. Even though you can find any number of lengths for Darn Tough socks, our favorite for general wear is the one you’ll find with this sock: mid-calf height.

Darn Tough Hiker Boot Sock Full Cushion

9.4/10Our Score

Performance Fit: No slipping, no bunching, and no blisters. True Seamless: Undetectable seam fusion for an ultrasmooth, invisible feel.
Fine Gauge Knitting: Unprecedented durability and our unique "put it on, forget it's on" feel.
Fast Action Wicking: Pulls moisture away from skin. Fast drying.
Merino Wool: The ultimate fiber for breathability and comfort in all conditions.
Still made in Vermont, USA. Still unconditionally guaranteed for life.

Check Amazon Check Darn Tough

2. Toughest Work Sock

Our next pick takes into account the individual who is working outdoors and is often wearing boots or heavy work shoes. The Darn Tough Steely sock is built to thrive and endure in those types of conditions and is designed with cushioning from the toe box to the top of the sock. This is truly a performance-wear sock that is built to resist heavy wear and tear while keeping your feet warm and comfortable.

Darn Tough Men's Steely Work Sock

8.9/10Our Score

Midweight with Cushion — A warm and extremely comfortable choice when conditions demand it, this fine gauge knitted sock provides mid-level cushion density under your foot. True Seamless technology allows for an undetectable seam fusion for an Ultra-smooth, invisible feel.
Boot Sock Height - Sits mid-calf for added protection and warmth. A sturdy companion.
Composition - Knit with 56% Merino Wool 41% Nylon 3% Lycra Spandex. The fast action wicking pulls moisture away from skin, so no more sweaty, stinky socks. The soft, breathable merino wool has fast drying, all weather performance that keeps you cool in the summer and warm in the winter.
Guaranteed for Life - Darn Tough's famous guarantee - if these socks wear, tear, or develop holes, Darn Tough will replace them no questions asked. No strings. No conditions.
Made in the USA - Every pair of socks is knit in Northfield, Vermont - the perfect testing ground for the finest premium all weather performance socks.

Check Amazon Check Darn Tough

3. Toughest Socks for Military & Firefighters

If you’re looking for a sock that is tough enough for our military, look no further than the Fox River sock. Excellent reviews and a popular choice for military families sending care packages to their loved ones. These socks don’t bunch up, wick moisture well and are fabricated using synthetic materials–as opposed to wool. As long as you keep your proof of purchase, Fox River will replace your socks if you reach out to their customer service team.

Fox River Adult Military Socks

8.4/10Our Score

Polypropylene is a synthetic water-repelling hydrophobic fiber won't accept moisture. This Multifilament yarn is virtually abrasion resistant, durable and stain resistant
Our exclusive WICK Dry technology quickly draws moisture away from your skin so your feet stay dry and comfortable. Removing the moisture build up reduces hot spots and friction that causes blisters
Scentry technology, scentry helps permanently defend your socks from odor. This is accomplished by an embedded fiber like silver or copper or with a micro polymer silane technology which slows wear & reduces odor in the sock
Our urfit system provides the ultimate personalized response fit combining memory knit compression, a contoured rib top and spandex compression zones
Memory-knit construction utilizes Spandex knit throughout the sock which gives memory-fit to help keep its shape wash after wash, Wear after wear

Check Amazon

4. Toughest Hiking & Backpacking Socks

If you’re looking for the best hiking, backpacking or aggresive outdoor activity sock option, look no farther than the Darn Tough Coolmax Micro Crew Midweight Hiking sock. Even though these socks perform wonderfully in the winter, this is our go-to sock for outdoor hiking in the summer or when you need to give your feet some ability to cool down. With this particular sock, Darn Tough uses synthetic fibers (Coolmax) to help wick moisture away from your skin–and keep your feet dry and comfortable. Like all of Darn Tough’s socks, these sock are durable, extremely long-lasting and come with a lifetime warranty-no strings attached.

Darn Tough Coolmax Micro Crew Socks

10/10Our Score

Coolmax Engineered to move moisture away from your skin and dry fast in warm conditions.
The perfect sock for runners looking to lose bulk without sacrificing cushioning and comfort when the weather gets hot
True Seamless construction reduces hotspots and blisters
Still made in Vermont, USA
Unconditionally guaranteed for life
37% Nylon, 34% Coolmax Polyester, 26% Acrylic, 2% Lycra Spandex, 1% Other fiber
True Seamless Undetectable seam fusion for an ultra smooth, invisible feel.

Check Amazon Check Darn Tough

5. Toughest Socks for Lounging Aroung the House

This review wouldn’t be complete without our personal favorite category–the toughest sock for loafing around the house. Although there were many contenders and the testing was rigorous, we have a hands-down favorite we’re thrilled to recommend: the Cloudline Merino Wool sock. Although there is a variety of different models, we prefer the medium cushion sock. With high Merino wool content and a relatively thick build, these socks last forever and will ease you into any lazy day where visions of warm beaches and tropical drinks can be induced by these socks. Although they’re a little thick for our taste when it comes to warm-weather hiking, these are some of the best socks we’ve ever found and wear beautifully over time.

CloudLine Merino Wool Socks

9.7/10Our Score

Our MEDIUM CUSHION socks have cushion throughout the foot for comfort and warmth

The Cloudline 100% satisfaction guarantee: You can be confident that you are going to love these socks as much as we do, or your money back
Made in the USA
Ultra fine premium merino wool
63% Ultra Soft Merino Wool, 33% Nylon, 4% Spandex

Check Amazon Check Walmart

6. Toughest Socks for Hunting & Fishing

Our next toughest sock pick revolves around the toughest of outdoor extreme-weather activities: hunting and fishing. Even though hunting obviously gets most of the attention for extreme weather, we’re assuming your fishing trips involve getting your feet wet at times and perhaps some early spring or late fall outings. As much as we tried to diversity our recommendations, we couldn’t in good conscience recommend anything other than Darn Tough’s badest, burliest sock–the heavyweight full-calf Darn Tough Hunting Sock. Even though these are about as good as it gets for hunting and fishing, these are also highly recommended for firefighters and anybody wearing boots in extreme weather conditions.

Darn Tough Hunter Heavyweight Socks

9.8/10Our Score

Heavyweight with Full Cushion - High density cushioning throughout the entire sock for full on comfort and performance. The most comfortable and warm option Darn Tough offers. True Seamless technology allows for an undetectable seam fusion for an ultra-smooth, invisible feel.
Over-The-Calf Height - The name says it all. The ultimate height for keeping the outside—out.
Composition - Knit with 79% Merino Wool 19% Nylon 2% Lycra Spandex. The fast action wicking pulls moisture away from skin, so no more sweaty, stinky socks. The soft, breathable merino wool has fast drying, all weather performance that keeps you cool in the summer and warm in the winter.
Guaranteed for Life - If these socks wear, tear, or develop holes, Darn Tough will replace them. No strings. No conditions.
Made in the USA - Every pair of socks is knit in Northfield, Vermont - the perfect testing ground for the finest premium all-weather performance socks.

Check Amazon Check Darn Tough

7. Toughest Socks for Sking & Snowboarding

Because this article is meant to help you pick the toughest socks in the world, we would be remiss if we didn’t wrap up our selection with the toughest (and most effective) ski and snowboard socks. Since we primarily ski in New England and Colorado, we definitely know a thing or two about which socks are going to carry you through a long, cold winter day. In all fairness, even though we’ve used this sock for years, it’s not padded and not very thick. That’s mainly because we believe in relying on higher-quality boots for increased warmth and comfort since socks can only do so much for you compared to your boots. With that in mind, we recommend browsing Backcountry.com for sales in their ski and snowboard sock section.

Darn Tough Captain America Ski Socks

8.7/10Our Score

Lightweight - Built light, darn comfy and super strong—substantial construction for a lightweight, sure fit. True Seamless technology allows for an undetectable seam fusion for an ultra-smooth, invisible feel.
Over-The-Calf-Height - The name says it all. The ultimate height for keeping the outside—out.
Composition - Knit with 60% Merino Wool 36% Nylon 4% Lycra Spandex. The fast action wicking pulls moisture away from skin, so no more sweaty, stinky socks. The soft, breathable merino wool has fast drying, all weather performance that keeps you cool in the summer and warm in the winter.
Guaranteed for Life - If these socks wear, tear, or develop holes, Darn Tough will replace them. No strings. No conditions.
Made in the USA - Every pair of socks is knit in Northfield, Vermont - the perfect testing ground for the finest premium all weather performance socks.

Check Amazon Check Darn Tough

What are the Toughest Socks Made of?

Most of the socks we’ve picked include a significant amount of Merino wool, but also often include synthetic fibers, such as polyester or a proprietary version of polyester. We typically prefer a sock that has been manufactured with a high amount of Merino Wool since it’s a very soft, durable and odor-resist material. Thankfully, it also isn’t itchy and has very favorable thermal-stable properties that will help regulate your feet temperature in all seasons; even in New England.

Merino wool is much finer and softer than regular wool and is grown by Merino sheep that graze the highlands of Australia and New Zealand. Since the 12th century, when the Merino breed originated, the sheep have developed the softest and finest fleece, which makes them perfect for socks. Clothing made of merino wool can withstand temperatures ranging from -20 C° up to +35 C°. With modern-day spinning technology and fiber treatments, merino wool makes for outstanding fabrics that outclass materials such as cotton or synthetics on all fronts.

Although Merino Wool holds up to extreme weather conditions and aggressive wear well, it will wear down over time; especially if you don’t care for your socks appropriately. We offer some tips at the end of this article about washing and caring for your socks.

Why So Many Darn Tough Sock Recommendations?

First, it’s not surprising that the toughest socks are manufactured in the heart of New England–Vermont. New England is a part of the country with extreme weather conditions much of the year and Vermont prides itself on craftsmanship. Darn Tough prides itself on making the most durable socks and not surprisingly offers a lifetime guarantee on its products–no question asked. Even though we focused mainly on extreme weather and wear activities, Darn Tough also makes socks that work for just about every other activity imaginable: running, walking, kayaking, cycling, mountain biking, skiing–whatever you love doing outside. Of course, they don’t match all of their socks to specific activities, but some basic research and analysis will help you arrive at the right selection.

Merino Wool Socks vs Regular Socks

Merino wool makes for an exceptional fabric choice for manufacturing socks. Unlike cotton or most synthetic fabrics, they act as a great temperature regulator. They work as an insulator in winters and keep your feet toasty. Even in summers, these socks are a great choice.

Merino wool has excellent moisture-wicking properties and keeps your skin dry during a workout. The fabric is also lighter, extra porous, more durable, and highly sustainable than its counterparts.

How to Care for Merino Wool Socks

Machine wash in cool or warm water. Avoid hot water. Darn Tough offers some helpful advice about washing your wool socks.
Use mild soap, and don’t use any bleach or softener.
Prefer air-dry. If you are tumble-drying, always use a low setting.
Check the label and follow instructions

How to Extend the Life of your Wool Socks

Below is a list of tips that will assist you in keeping your socks in their best condition for as long as possible. Keep in mind that even though you can follow each step below, there’s really no better way to prolong the life of your socks than to buy the highest quality socks available.

1. Hot or cold water?

Always wash your socks in cold water. When you wash socks in hot water, it accelerates the aging process by wearing away at the material or fibers the sock is made of.

2. Wash your socks at home

As opposed to taking your socks to dry cleaner, just wash them at home. You just don’t know what a dry cleaner or someone outside of your home will do to your socks.

3. Turn them inside out when washing

Taking the time to turn your socks inside out will help you remove the sweat you’ve accumulated on your socks. Also, when you forgo this step too often, you’ll almost certainly gather quite a bit of lint on your socks over time.

4. Wash socks of different color separately

It is also a good practice to follow when washing socks and just about anything else. To help take some of the work out of this, we throw our wool socks into their own bin so we’re able to wash them more easily without mixing them with other types of clothing.

5. Be gentle

If you have a solid washer/dryer, rely on the gentle cycle.

6. Avoid bleach

Bleach will deteriorate your socks quicker than anything else you can do. You may not see them develop, but it’s likely that you’ll begin to slowly eat away at the thinner and more worn part of your socks, which will almost surely result in new holes forming over time.

7. Skip fabric softener

Fabric softener contains a number of different chemicals. Keep in mind that socks made of merino wool typically don’t absorb odor anyway, so a very mild soap will be sufficient to address whatever dirt or scent needs to be removed.

8. Use mild detergent

Use a mild soap if you use soap at all. We really like a detergent-like Ms. Meyers Detergent. The harsher the laundry detergent, the more likely that the detergent will wear down your socks.

9. No ironing

Just don’t do it–no need since you’ll be hanging your socks up to dry.

10. Hang them up

Just hang them on a drying rack and leave them alone for a while. We like using a standard drying rack.

11. Don’t wring them dry

Wringing your socks can stretch them.

12. Store socks flat

Similar to wringing your socks, your goal is to preserve the natural shape of your socks over time. Storing them flat will help ensure they retain their original shape.

The post Toughest Socks appeared first on New England Gear Guide.